What are the Different Flavors of Rum Cake?
What makes rum cake so infamous?
For starters, rum cakes are the lovechild of something sweet and something strong, blending sugary tastes with the potency of alcohol—specifically, rum.
Whether you’re in the mood for old fashioned coconut rum cake or pina colada cake with rum, Aunt Agnes Cakes should be on your radar.
Since 2021, Aunt Agnes Cakes has worked with centuries-old recipes passed down from Aunt Agnes herself: A woman who lived long enough to revive and revolutionize the way we eat Jamaican rum cake.
When baked right, each slice of rum cake provides a small dose of rum. But, only if done right. More often than not, recipes are modified to include too much rum or too little. In that case, you won’t be able to enjoy the natural infusion of flavors.
With all those years of experience under our belt, we’d like to share the ultimate rum cake flavors list. Give any of these flavors a try and you’ll never look back!
What are the Different Flavors of Rum Cake?
From pineapple to coconut, where do we even begin?
With all of our years making and baking cakes, we’ve compiled the best Caribbean rum cake flavors list just for you: 1) Coconut Rum Cake, 2) Pina Colada Rum Cake, 3) Pineapple Rum Cake, and 4) Jamaican Rum Fruit Cake.
This list is not exhaustive—dozens did not make the cut—so feel free to widen your palate even further when you browse our collection!
For now, let’s start with a crowd favorite . . .
Picture of Coconut Rum Cake | Aunt Agnes Cakes
1. Coconut Rum Cake
Pairing coconut cake with rum is enough to create its own unique dessert.
Made with a blend of premium Jamaican rum and creamy coconut milk, Coconut Rum Cake gives you a quick taste of the Caribbean. Each bite is sweet from the fruit and strong from the alcohol, but the texture is soft when the rum bakes evenly throughout the cake pan.
Consider snagging our coconut rum bundt cake or full-sized coconut rum cake to see what you’re missing out on!
Picture of Pina Colada Rum Cake | Aunt Agnes Cakes
2. Pina Colada Rum Cake
On their own, Pina Coladas are made with coconut, pineapple juice and white rum. When used to create rum cakes, the flavors stand out so much better!
The Pina Colada adds the sweetness, while the Jamaican premium rum carries the edge. Now, all that’s needed is the right recipe to fuse those flavors together.
Anyone can bake a pina colada rum cake with pineapples. But, unfortunately, not everyone can do the age-old recipe justice. Thankfully, our Pina Colada Rum Cake does just that!
Picture of Pineapple Rum Cake | Aunt Agnes Cakes
3. Pineapple Rum Cake
Can’t get enough of pineapples? You’re in luck with our next option: Pineapple Rum Cakes!
Each bite of an old fashioned pineapple rum cake brings you to the tropics. By combining pineapple juice and premium rum, this dessert stands the test of time as one of the most beloved rum cake flavors!
If you’re struggling between Coconut Rum Cake or Pineapple Rum Cake, why not try both? This batch combines coconut rum cake with pineapple to make the perfect sweet treat!
Picture of Jamaican Rum Fruit Cake | Aunt Agnes Cakes
4. Jamaican Rum Fruit Cake
Are we cheating if we include Christmas cake?
We couldn’t create our Jamaican rum cake flavors list without mentioning Rum Fruit Cake.
Usually served around the holidays, a slice of old fashioned rum fruit cake uses more alcohol than the others on this list. That’s because Jamaican rum fruit cakes combine rum, wine and a blend of fruits!
If you’re a fan of traditional desserts—with an alcoholic twist—you should know the best place to shop Jamaican rum fruit cake for sale! Look no further than here at Aunt Agnes Cakes, and order full-sized cakes or miniature ones year-round!
Picture of Pineapple Rum Bundt Cakes | Aunt Agnes Cakes
Where Can I Find Jamaican Rum Cake In Florida?
Based in Fort Lauderdale, Aunt Agnes Cakes is a Jamaican-owned bakery specializing in your favorite (or soon-to-be favorite) rum cake recipes!
From fruit cakes to rum cakes, we know our way around the kitchen. So, let us reiterate: What are the different flavors of rum cake?
Coconut Rum Cakes supply enough sweetness for total beginners. If you’re palate craves something more tangy, either Pineapple Rum Cake or Pina Colada Rum Cake is your next best bet. Though, you can’t go wrong with classics: That is, the traditional Jamaican Rum Fruit Cake!
Interested in giving rum cakes a try? Consider ordering one from us or request a custom cake using our contact form! Aunt Agnes Cakes deliver Jamaican desserts near Fort Lauderdale—plus locally to other Miami and Florida locations
From the ‘buzz’ of the rum to the sweetness of the fruit(s) within, rum cakes are a staple part of any sweet tooth’s diet! Everyone should try it at least once in their lives. What’s your excuse?
